There's been a lot of discussion lately about the plans to build a mosque just a short distance from the World Trade Center site in New York City. While I've not followed the discussion that closely, and so I must admit to not knowing all the details as perhaps I should, I still thought I'd post something brief about how I'm thinking about this issue based on what facts I know.
First, let me say as an American it makes me uncomfortable...but there's no law against being uncomfortable. In fact sometimes it is a very good thing to be made uncomfortable. Often in our discomfort our own views and opinions come more solidly into focus, and I don't see how that can ever really be a bad thing.
Second, I've heard this argument...would the Muslims allow a Christian church or a Jewish synagogue to be built in Mecca? Well...no. But isn't that precisely the point? We aren't in Mecca and we aren't controlled by a single religious group. As Americans we are guided by a different set of principles, so this argument seems weak to me at best. My home is a country that stands for the freedom to practice my religious convictions freely...even when that practice may make other people profoundly uncomfortable. I want to be free to build a Christian church wherever one is most needed.
Third, as a Baptist it is a foundational tenet of our Christian conviction that a person should be free to worship as he pleases. Therefore, at great risk I must take unpopular stands from time to time in order to see that belief made reality. I want to be free to worship as a Christian wherever I want. If I were a Muslim should I be forced to put my Muslim faith on hold simply because I'm standing in a place where some people from a radical element of my religious practice did a truly horrible, evil act? As Christians we are not exempt from having done truly horrible things in the name of Christianity. Remember the crusades? Remember slavery in America? Tragically, as a believer I must acknowledge that people in my own faith have done some utterly dispicable things in the name of Christianity. Does this mean we should not be allowed to practice Christianity in the south...or build Christian church buildings there?
On some level it seems to me that the construction of the mosque on this particular site would be truly honoring to the men and women who have died because of what happened there on September 11, 2001...because it was precisely because they were Americans standing up for American ideals like freedom of religion...even when that practice may be truly uncomfortable.
So yes, it makes me uncomfortable to have a mosque built on that particular site, but for the life of me I see no reason why they shouldn't be free to do it. Discomfort is not a reason. Political correctness is not a reason.
I am thankful that at least for now, my home is a country where I am free to be made uncomfortable, because the time may come when they'll come after me and after my own religious convictions...and then who will stand up for me?
Homemaking: Divine, Not Demeaning
4 hours ago
